Panama City, Florida

Scroll down to the New News Section for current promotions, info, etc.

Our Story 


40th Street Pizza is owned and operated by siblings Patricia Cournoyer, Michael Mifsud, and Christine Boyer. Our lifelong dream came true when we purchased the existing restaurant in May 2017.  We have been serving up the same signature pizza Mexico Beach has known and loved for 17 years!  In June of 2018, our landlord sold the Mexico Beach building so we moved to the Hickory Plaza in Parker, FL.  We worked tirelessly to remodel the former laundromat and finally opened our doors on September 27, 2018.  And then, 13 days later, Hurricane Michael took it all away.  We are determined though.....we found this little restaurant next to Home Depot in Panama City and this is now our home! 

40th Street Pizza is a piece of our own personal family history. We pledge to our customers to provide great food and service to any and every one who comes by!


Now delivering with Postmates!

Now delivering with DoorDash!

New News

NEW HOURS Effective February 15, 2021

Sun, Mon, Wed, Thu  11:00am - 7:00pm


Fri and Sat  11:00am - 8:00pm

We have partnered with Redbubble, a print on demand company, to bring our logo and Taylor's artwork to you! Redbubble carries a long list of products, from coffee mugs to Tshirts to comforters. Our artwork is available to print on all their products. The quality is great (we have sample products in our restaurant for you to view)! Christmas is right around the corner!!
Visit our page at

We now have Crustless Pizza!! The delicious pizza you love without the crust. Available in Meat Lovers, Supreme and House Specialty. $8.99 each.  Each order is enough for one meal.....all the protein and none of the crust!

We have removed the following items from our menu:


Chicken Tetrazinni


Chocolate Cake

PB & J Sandwich

We apologize for any inconvenience.

Our famous, homemade Sausage Gravy is now available to purchase, frozen, by the pint or quart. Pint cost is $4.69 (gravy covers 1-2 open faced biscuits). Quart cost is $8.29 (gravy covers 2-4 open faced biscuits). Biscuits not included.

HAPPY HOUR Monday and Wednesdays 5:00 pm-8:00 pm

Buy 1 pizza and get a 2nd pizza 1/2 off


or a FREE order of breadsticks

  • Ask us about catering your next party or office meeting! We can prepare your choice of items for 6 to 100 people. We cannot offer set up, servers or clean up at this time due to the diminished area work force. Give us a call or send an email to for more details.​

  • Did you know that all orders of 5 or more pizzas, any size, will automatically receive 10% off their entire order?

  • Don't forget you can order a pickup online through our website! Click the link at the bottom of this newsletter to see our story, view our menu and place your order (we do not offer payment through the website with debit or credit cards at this time).

  • Check out our Facebook and Instagram pages for more updates, including specials and images of our many delicious menu items.


401-I E. 23rd Street

(next to Home Depot, behind O'Charley's)

Panama City, FL 32405

Sun, Mon, Wedn, Thurs  11:00AM – 7:00PM


Friday - Saturday            11:00AM – 8:00PM


Tel: (850) 215-4413


40th Street Pizza -- Best Pizza For Miles!


All prices posted and displayed by this business represent the cash discount. Credit Card users are subject to a 3.982% convenience fee.